I don’t want to talk about Josh Duggar in this post except to say two things: The first being that the recent media attention of his case is why I’ve felt prompted to write this article, and the second that this article is in *no way* condoning his actions. They were wrong and horrible, no matter what age he was. But this article is not about Josh Duggar.
Everywhere I see news of this issue, it’s guaranteed to be in one of a couple different contexts. One is that “these people” were so against gay rights and claimed gay people were child molesters so this is hypocritical of them. The other is to attack Christians and give no concern to the victims in these cases, instead choosing to use the opportunity to present an anti-religious stance.
I won’t pretend to know what those girls went through. I have had similarly difficult times in my life, but never under such circumstances. Every article that attacks their family is an attack on them as well. You can imagine they must feel victimized all over again each time. Had this happened to you, the last thing you’d want is such a public mockery of your life. Everyone who believes in a higher power of some sort has the right to connect with that higher power however they see fit, provided it doesn’t harm another person. These girls are being told by everything they would find about their family and their religion right now that they are wrong and bad. How does that help the victims of this?
I grew up in a very strict religion. You could say it’s similar to some of the descriptions I have heard of the Duggars’ faith, though probably not as strict. There are accusations of horrible things from nearly every religious denomination. I’ve always found it curious that it seems the more strict or smaller denominations come under fire for this more harshly than larger religions. The faith I grew up in never claimed to be perfect. Your typical faithful person won’t do that. And though it is not my choice of a religion anymore, I have respect for the people still in it who choose to walk that path.
It’s so rare in life that something is 100% good or 100% evil. So very rare. It’s also rare to find even two people who are exactly alike, so imagine lumping an entire religious group into one stereotype and assuming no one can be any different. I have met so many wonderful religious people who live a very strict life. I have met awful ones as well. I have met kind and loving atheists and I have met some really awful ones. The world is not black and white.
The second that the media turned this into a political debate was when those victims lost, again. You can’t blame religion for a person’s actions. You can’t blame your past. Everyone needs to take responsibility for themselves. I won’t attest to if Josh has done that or not. As I said, this article is not about that. It’s about the immediate need for blame on a religion or faith instead of on the individual. It’s about these girls being victimized ten years ago and having to relive it all now through vicious attacks on their family from just about every source.
In the end we can’t possibly know how they feel. We can’t possibly know what will happen or what happened exactly back then. But I do know this – I know that blaming religion or an anti-gay stance for this is not going to help anyone. Until the discussion can be grey and not black and white, the conversations between religious people and anti-religious people will never get anywhere. Life exists in grey. Try to meet in the middle and see.
Jessie Ivanowski
Latest posts by Jessie Ivanowski (see all)
- You Can’t Always Get What You Want - December 20, 2019
- But What About the Children? - March 28, 2016
- Unicorn Hunting - February 23, 2016
“By their fruits, ye shall know them.” Matthew 7:16
When harm is done, the main problem is that we don’t have any recourse. Religion is like a corporation. Lots of rights, lots of privileges, no accountability. Christians are quick to wash their hands of the acts of “fundamentalists” or “extremists”. But once a good thing comes by, they’re quick to count it as part of themselves. It’s a classic example of the Texas sharpshooter fallacy.
“These girls are being told by everything they would find about their family and their religion right now that they are wrong and bad. How does that help the victims of this?”
The “political debate” (as you called it later in your article) needs to be heard, and it isn’t mutually exclusive to the recovery of the victims. It should be noted that their recovery was explicitly prevented because of the religion that they adhere to.
Not a single person has said that they are wrong and bad. What I’m saying is that the religion is wrong and bad. The Christian cultivation of a victim-blaming culture is wrong and bad. The lack of education and control over sexuality, a direct cause of the issue that can be directly attributed to Christianity, is wrong and bad.
I’m not lumping an entire religious group into a stereotype. I’m pointing out what has become a systematic abortion of justice made evident time and time again as followers of Christianity continually erode the freedom and safety of everyone around them. Victim blaming, as taught by the leaders of their church, is never okay.
“You can’t blame religion for a person’s actions.”
Beliefs lead to actions, actions lead to consequences. The Christian faith has clearly demonstrated its responsibility for what happened. Silence the messenger tactics, which are liberally employed throughout your article, won’t ever work.